As far as titles go, “The Bone Collector” sounds like it ought to be the tale of a forlorn archaeologist, unable to connect on a personal level with any living person until he meets the girl of his dream who brings him out of his shell and he finds love and discovers there’s more to life than hunting for bones in the desert. *Sigh* However, in this case, “The Bone Collector” turns out to be a cookie-cutter, garden-variety, thriller-novel-turned-thrill-free-movie that tries to be Silence of the Lambs but to actually watch soundless lambs is approximately twice as entertaining.
Taking away that rather cryptic summary and just examining the ingredients, there’s a lot going for The Bone Collector to be a good movie. Of course, filet mignon, chocolate, french toast, and grapes are great, but not necessarily together if you catch my drift.
The Bone Collector has a good director in Phillip Noyce, the man behind the best of the Jack Ryan films and one of the better political thrillers, Clear and Present Danger. The stars are no less than two of the best actors working, Denzel Washington and Angelina Jolie (before she was an A-lister). And it’s based on a novel – and all novels are inherently good, right? Still, at best the movie feels like you are witnessing spare parts of better movies and at worst like they were kind of making the story up as they went. I believe the great Michael J. Nelson once referred to a movie made from leftovers of better flicks as a “movieloaf” – and the Bone Collector is the perfect embodiment of a movieloaf.
(more…)